The short answer is no. The three main types of bark collars have about the same level of effectiveness in controlling your dog’s barking.
Whether you’re getting a shock bark collar, citronella bark collar, or sonic bark collar, your dog is going to stop barking. It’s a no-thought, no-nonsense way to get your dog to stop barking excessively. About 35% of dog owners have problems with their dogs’ barking, and you probably fall into that category if you’re reading this article.
The evidence shows that shock collars and other types of no-bark collars work about the same in side-by-side comparisons. Shock collars are highly effective, though, just like other types of bark collars. Now that we cleared that up you may be wondering what are the best bark collars on the market today. Read on to learn more about bark collars and then we will cover that topic as well.
How Does an Electric Shock Collar Work?
An electric shock collar works by detecting vibrations in the dog’s vocal chords or picking up the sound of barking on a microphone embedded into the collar. The best types of bark collars use both to cut down on the chance of false alarms. Nothing could be worse for your poor dog than for it to be near heavy traffic, a block party, or other dogs and have its bark collar shock it repeatedly because of outside noise. The best bark collars use two layers of detection to ensure that no outside noises activate the electric shock mechanism.
To get a bit more technical, there are two metal prongs that are in contact with your dog’s neck. The mechanism that’s touching the dog’s throat sends out a static shock that travels along those prongs when it senses barking. Because the prongs are resting against your dog’s neck, it will jolt him instantly. You have the ability to set the dial to whatever intensity level you want. You can test it on yourself at each intensity level and see what it feels like.
Just rest it against your hand and activate it by remote control. Then you’ll known firsthand (pun intended) what it feels like. Some bark collars are set to increase the intensity automatically if your dog keeps barking past the first shock. And, some let you set the intensity at a fixed level. Many of them come with a remote control and deactivation option so you can shock your dog whenever he’s barking at something you don’t like. This is in contrast to your dog getting shocked automatically when he barks.
Is an Electric Shock Collar Dangerous?
Despite the warnings and castigation of some animal activists, alarmist authors, and animal rights organizations, bark collars are in fact perfectly safe. While they might sound like they’d be dangerous or harmful, they’re not at all. Just don’t use it improperly, though. As we described above, you can even test it by placing the collar on your hand and activating it. You’ll see that it’s not painful at all. Set it to the lowest intensity level possible if you’re worried. It should be sufficient to get your dog to stop barking. The goal is not to punish or harm your dog, but just to get him to not want to bark because it’s annoying to get shocked.
The industry obviously claims that no harm is done to the dog, and you can feel it for yourself and see that it’s not painful. Still, the shock is something the dog doesn’t like. If it didn’t annoy them in some way, then they would just keep barking.
How do Bark Collars Work?
There are many types of bark collars on the market, many of which have several levels of stimulation that work in conjunction with how well the dog learns. In other words, the collars adapt to your dog’s willingness to stop barking. If the dog doesn’t stop barking, the collar will ratchet up in intensity until it does. They work in a way that gives the time dog to understand and recover.
What Are the Other Types of Bark Collars?
This article was about whether shock collars worked better than the other types of bark collars. We answered no. But what are the other types of bark collars? We mentioned them briefly above. The two other main types of collars are citronella bark collars and ultrasonic bark collars. The citronella bark collar has a mechanism that sends out a scented liquid citronella spray when your dog starts to bark excessively. Most dogs hate the smell of citronella, and they will stop barking. With an ultrasonic bark collar, it sends out a very unpleasant, high-pitched sound that only dogs can hear. Any of the three options is fine. It’s all just a matter of personal preference.
Some people have a psychological problem with electric shock collars. It’s not a rational thing. They just have a personal problem with the idea of a shock of any kind jolting their dog’s neck. Even though they know logically it doesn’t cause them any real pain, they just don’t like the idea of it. You may be one of those people. That’s fine. If that’s the case, then just pick up a different kind of shock collar. There are many options available. You can get one that just sends out sprays or noises. Remember, bark collars aren’t harmful to begin with.
If you’re thinking about getting a bark collar, then you’re one of the millions of people who have trouble with their dogs’ barking and don’t know what to do. You might feel like a helpless pet owner with no end in sight to that incessant, noisy barking. Many dog owners feel just like you. They don’t have the time, energy, or money to train their dogs or have someone else do it. You can put an end to your suffering today by just purchasing a bark collar. You will get near-instant relief. Your dog will quickly learn to stop barking, and you can rest easy at home once again.